When Paying Off Debt Helps Your Loan Qualify
Lenders often see borrowers pay off debts right before closing to improve their debt-to-income ratio. This strategy can work, but underwriters scrutinize it carefully. They want to see that you're not just shuffling money around to barely qualify.
Say you have a car loan with 8 months of payments left at $350 per month. If you pay this off before closing, that $350 monthly payment disappears from your DTI calculation. The same applies to any installment loan with 10 or fewer payments remaining — you can exclude it from your qualifying ratios even without paying it off.
Credit cards work differently but offer more flexibility. If you plan to pay off a credit card with a $5,000 balance and $150 minimum payment at closing, that $150 monthly obligation gets removed from your DTI. You don't have to close the account. The lender just needs proof you'll have the funds to pay it off.
How Lenders Verify Your Payoff Plans
Your lender needs documentation showing you can actually pay off these debts. For installment loans, they'll want a payoff statement from the creditor showing the exact amount needed to satisfy the loan.
For credit cards and revolving accounts, you'll need recent statements and proof of funds. The money to pay off these debts must be in addition to your down payment, closing costs, and required reserves. You can't use the same $10,000 for both your down payment and to pay off credit cards.
If you already paid off accounts before applying, bring proof of payoff instead of tying up additional funds. A zero balance statement or payoff letter from the creditor satisfies this requirement.
The Special Rules for 30-Day Charge Accounts
American Express and some business charge accounts that require full payment each month get special treatment. If your credit report shows no monthly payment amount, or if the payment equals the full balance, the lender must verify you have funds to cover the entire balance.
These funds must be separate from your closing costs and reserves. If you have a $3,000 charge account balance, you need an extra $3,000 in verified assets beyond what you need to close the loan.
Desktop Underwriter automatically includes these balances in your required reserves calculation. For cash-out refinances, DU may reduce this requirement by the amount of cash you're receiving.
What Must Be Paid Off Before Closing
Certain debts have no wiggle room — they must be satisfied before you can close. This includes all collections accounts, charge-offs on non-mortgage accounts, judgments, tax liens, mechanic's liens, and any liens that could affect the lender's position on the property.
Federal tax debts with IRS payment plans get special attention. If you have an installment agreement with the IRS but there's a federal tax lien recorded in the county where you're buying, you must pay off the entire tax debt at closing. The monthly payment plan won't suffice when a lien exists on public record.
For more details on how tax payment plans work in other situations, see [[B3-6-05]].
Small Collections May Get a Pass
Manual underwriting offers some relief for small collection accounts. Individual non-medical collections under $250 each, or total collections under $1,000, don't require payoff at closing. This applies only to non-medical collections and charge-offs on non-mortgage accounts.
A borrower with three small collections — $150, $200, and $180 — totaling $530 wouldn't need to pay them off. But someone with collections of $300, $400, and $500 totaling $1,200 would need to satisfy all of them before closing.
Desktop Underwriter has its own rules for collections that may differ from manual underwriting standards. See [[B3-5.3-09]] for DU-specific requirements.
Why These Rules Exist
Fannie Mae requires debt payoffs to ensure borrowers aren't overextended and that the property serves as proper collateral. Liens and judgments can cloud the title or give other creditors claims against the property. Collections and charge-offs suggest past payment problems that could resurface.
The 10-payment rule for installment loans recognizes that short-term debts don't represent long-term obligations. A car loan with 6 months left won't burden your finances for years to come.
The flexibility with revolving accounts acknowledges that these credit lines might be useful after closing. You might need that credit card for moving expenses or home repairs. Closing accounts can also hurt your credit score by reducing available credit.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Don't assume you can pay off debts with loan proceeds. The money must come from your own verified assets. If you're doing a cash-out refinance, you might use some of those proceeds, but the lender needs to see this clearly documented.
Timing matters for payoffs. If you pay off accounts too early in the process, they might not show as paid on your credit report by closing. If you wait too long, you might not have time to get proper documentation.
Be careful with joint accounts. If you're married but only one spouse is on the mortgage, paying off the other spouse's debts might not help your DTI ratio. The lender looks at the borrower's obligations, not the household's.
Watch out for closed accounts that still show balances. Sometimes accounts appear paid off but still carry small balances for interest or fees. Get a zero balance letter to avoid last-minute surprises.
References
For the official guidelines, see B3-6-07: Debts Paid Off At or Prior to Closing in the Fannie Mae Selling Guide.
Mortgage guidelines change. Stay current.
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac update their rules several times a year. Get notified when changes affect your mortgage eligibility, required documents, or loan terms.
No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
Original Fannie Mae Guideline Text
B3-6-07, Debts Paid Off At or Prior to Closing (04/05/2023)
Payoff or Paydown of Debt for Qualification
Open 30-Day Charge Accounts
Collections, Charge-Offs of Non-Mortgage Accounts, Judgments, and Liens
Payoff or Paydown of Debt for Qualification
Payoff or paydown of debt solely to qualify must be carefully evaluated and considered in the overall loan analysis. The borrower’s history of credit use should be a factor in determining whether the appropriate approach is to include or exclude debt for qualification. Generally
Installment loans that are being paid off or paid down to 10 or fewer remaining monthly payments do not need to be included in the borrower’s long-term debt.
If a revolving account balance is to be paid off at or prior to closing, a monthly payment on the current outstanding balance does not need to be included in the borrower's long-term debt, i.e., not included in the debt-to-income (DTI) ratio. Such accounts do not need to be closed as a condition of excluding the payment from the DTI ratio.
See B3-6-02, Debt-to-Income Ratios for additional guidance on calculating total monthly obligations for qualifying purposes.
Open 30-Day Charge Accounts
For open 30-day charge accounts that do not reflect a monthly payment on the credit report, or 30-day accounts that reflect a monthly payment that is identical to the account balance, lenders must verify borrower funds to cover the account balance. The verified funds must be in addition to any funds required for closing costs and reserves.
Note: DU will include the balance of the 30-day charge accounts on the loan application in the Reserves Required to be Verified amount shown on the DU Underwriting Findings report. However, for transactions that do not require the verification of reserves, the balance of 30–day charge accounts in the Reserves Required to be Verified amount will be reduced by any cash out the borrower will receive through the transaction.
If the borrower paid off the account balance prior to closing, the lender may provide proof of payoff in lieu of verifying funds to cover the account balance.
Collections, Charge-Offs of Non-Mortgage Accounts, Judgments, and Liens
Delinquent credit—including taxes, judgments, charge-offs of non-mortgage accounts (see below for exceptions), tax liens, mechanic's or materialmen’s liens, and liens that have the potential to affect Fannie Mae’s lien position or diminish the borrower’s equity—must be paid off at or prior to closing.
Delinquent federal income taxes that are approved to be paid by a monthly installment agreement with the IRS must be paid in full at or prior to closing if there is any indication that a Notice of Federal Tax Lien has been recorded against the borrower in the county in which the subject property is located. For additional information about federal income tax installment agreements, see B3-6-05, Monthly Debt Obligations.
For details regarding delinquent federal income taxes that the IRS has approved to be paid through an installment agreement that can be included as a monthly debt obligation, rather than being paid in full, also see B3-6-05, Monthly Debt Obligations.
For manually underwritten loans, non-medical collection accounts and charge-offs on non-mortgage accounts do not have to be paid off at or prior to closing if the balance of an individual account is less than $250 or the total balance of all accounts is $1,000 or less. Non-medical collection accounts and charge-offs on non-mortgage accounts that exceed these limits must be paid off at or prior to closing.
For DU underwritten loans, refer to B3-5.3-09, DU Credit Report Analysis.
