Is it normal for homeowners insurance to be this expensive?
Key Takeaways
- Insurance costs depend on location, home age, size, and local weather risks.
- Your Closing Disclosure shows the annual premium and escrow deposits.
- Multiple quotes help you see the normal range for your property.
Is my homeowners insurance quote too high?
You're seeing a homeowners insurance quote that feels higher than expected and want to know if the cost is typical. Homeowners insurance premiums vary widely based on your home's location, age, size, and coverage amount, plus factors like local weather risks and claims history in your area. Insurance companies calculate premiums differently, so quotes can range significantly even for the same property. Your lender requires homeowners insurance before closing and will collect the first year's premium at settlement, plus additional months for your escrow account.
Check your Closing Disclosure for the exact insurance amount—it shows the annual premium and escrow deposits on page 2. Compare quotes from multiple insurers to see the range for your property. You can also adjust your deductible or coverage limits to change the premium, though higher deductibles mean more out-of-pocket costs if you file a claim. Share your quotes with your lender to confirm the escrow calculations and discuss any questions about the insurance requirements.
About the Author

Dan Green
20-year Mortgage Expert
Dan Green is a mortgage expert with over 20 years of direct mortgage experience. He has helped millions of homebuyers navigate their mortgages and is regularly cited by the press for his mortgage insights. Dan combines deep industry knowledge with clear, practical guidance to help buyers make informed decisions about their home financing.
Read more from Dan